Meteor vs S8: which needs more amplifier?

The Moondrop Meteor is 18.5Ω at 102.7 dB/mW; the Moondrop S8 is 16Ω at 104.0 dB/mW. This page covers what they ask of an amplifier, not how they sound.

The Meteor needs 1.3 dB more than the S8 to reach the same loudness — 0.54 mW against 0.40 mW.

The numbers that decide it

SpecificationMeteorS8
Impedance18.5 Ω16 Ω
Sensitivity102.7 dB/mW104.0 dB/mW
Sensitivity (voltage)120.0 dB/V122.0 dB/V
Power for 100 dB0.54 mW0.40 mW
Voltage for 100 dB100 mV80 mV
Current for 100 dB5.4 mA5.0 mA
Highest source impedance
that leaves them alone (one-eighth rule)
2.31 Ω2.00 Ω
Sources that reach 100 dB
out of 280
280280

Where the two part company

Every source in the database that drives one of them drives the other. On power, the choice between these two changes nothing about what amplifier you need.

2 sources stay below the audible-hiss threshold with the Meteor but cross it with the S8 (FiiO BTR11, Rupert Neve RNHP).

280 of the 280 sources here reach 100 dB on both.

What each one needs from 80 to 105 dB

The Meteor is more demanding than 31% of the 567 non-electrostatic models in this database; the S8 than 26%.

dB SPLMeteor powerMeteor voltageS8 powerS8 voltage
805.4 µW10 mV4.0 µW8 mV
850.02 mW18 mV0.01 mW14 mV
900.05 mW32 mV0.04 mW25 mV
950.17 mW56 mV0.13 mW45 mV
1000.54 mW100 mV0.40 mW80 mV
1051.7 mW0.18 V1.3 mW0.14 V

The cheapest source that satisfies both

SourcePriceHeadroom, MeteorHeadroom, S8Output impedanceNoise
JadeAudio JA11$2015.1 dB15.8 dB0.5 Ω1.7 µV
FiiO KA11$2926.3 dB27.9 dB0.7 Ω1.7 µV
FiiO BTR13$5923.2 dB24.8 dB0.6 Ω1.0 µV

Of the 280 sources here, 280 reach 100 dB on both. 67 of them also publish an output impedance low enough for both under the one-eighth rule and a noise figure that stays below the audible-hiss threshold with both.

The cheapest of the 67 is the JadeAudio JA11, at $20. It leaves 15.1 dB of headroom on the Meteor and 15.8 dB on the S8, its output impedance is 0.5 Ω against a one-eighth limit of 2.31 Ω and 2.00 Ω, and its noise figure puts the hiss floor 15 dB and 13 dB below the 20 dB SPL this site treats as the point where a quiet room stops hiding it.

Try any other source.

What each sheet prints, and what it is worth

ModelAs printedToleranceStandard
Meteor9Hz- 35kHznot printednot printed
 20Hz - 20kHz (IEC60318-4,3dB)3 dBIEC60318-4
S820-40kHznot printednot printed
 20-20kHznot printednot printed

Moondrop prints two ranges, “9Hz- 35kHz” and “20Hz - 20kHz (IEC60318-4,3dB)”, for the Meteor and two ranges, “20-40kHz” and “20-20kHz”, for the S8.

Only one of the two is a specification. The range printed for the Meteor comes with a tolerance; the one printed for the S8 does not, and a range without a ±dB figure says nothing about how loud that model is at either end of it. The two cannot be compared number against number, however similar they look in the table. Of the 490 models whose maker prints a range, 58 print the tolerance.

Not a measurement; maker by maker.

Both pages in full

Both have a page of their own. In full: Moondrop Meteor and Moondrop S8. Every figure on this page comes from what Moondrop published, or is derived from it — what that maker publishes, counted.

↑